It would be unfair to say that the Kansas City Chiefs would've been as dominant without Harrison Butker's contributions over the past decade. He used to be a guaranteed point-getter and one of the most reliable kickers in football, but those days are long gone.
Butker has plenty of emotional real estate in the building, and Andy Reid has always been a big supporter. However, this is a business first and foremost, and Butker isn't delivering a positive return on the team's investment due to his struggles.
That's why it wasn't surprising to see the Chiefs silently work out Matt Prater. And even though they didn't sign the veteran, they're already showing signs of being ready to move on from their struggling placekicker.
The Chiefs don't seem to know what to at kicker
The Chiefs had already stirred the pot by signing the controversial Justin Tucker to the practice squad. Coach Reid had to deal with scrutiny, backlash, and a myriad of questions regarding the team's decision to sign a once-great kicker who had faced serious off-field accusations, not to mention that he was also past his prime.
Prater's best years are also probably behind him. Nevertheless, the mere fact that they had the 42-year-old in the building for a workout speaks volumes about how they truly feel about Butker after such a bad season.
A 19-year veteran, Prater has been quite the journeyman, playing for the Atlanta Falcons, Denver Broncos, Detroit Lions, Arizona Cardinals, and Buffalo Bills. He hasn't played since the 2025 season, when he converted 23 of 25 field goal attempts and 46 of 49 PATs.
As for Butker, he's already missed seven field goals this season, including three in Weeks 7 through 9. He didn't attempt a field goal in the blowout win over the Atlanta Falcons, though he was money on five PATs.
Good teams focus on offense and/or defense, but great teams know they must dominate in every aspect of the game. Often overlooked, special teams also play a huge role in a team's success— or lack thereof.
The Chiefs' offense has been much better this season, with Kenneth Walker III wreaking havoc out of the backfield and Eric Bieniemy returning as offensive coordinator. Nevertheless, that doesn't mean Butker should get a pass.
It would be a shame to watch Travis Kelce's potentially final season go to waste and end prematurely because of Butker's miscues. And even if they don't sign Prater, it looks like they've finally admitted that they need someone else at the position.
