Heading into what could be the final year of Travis Kelce's legendary Kansas City Chiefs career, it is fitting to revisit his GOAT argument. What is so interesting about any reasonable argument against Kelce is the fact that some tend to value peak performance over the longevity of greatness. But contrary to what some may say, Travis Kelce has both.
Rob Gronkowski is pointed to as the most physically dominating tight end of any era, but he lacks the consistent stats and accomplishments of Kelce. Still, fans make the argument that the longtime New England Patriot was better based simply on the level of his proficiency in the blocking aspect of the game and his red zone capabilities. While this is understandable in some ways, it is important to point out that Gronk wasn't available at the level Kelce has been, and that health does play a factor in each GOAT case in every sport.
Name | Games Played | Receiving Yards | Touchdowns | Pro Bowl Selections | 1st Team All-Pros | Super Bowl Wins |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tony Gonzalez | 270 | 15,127 | 111 | 14 | 6 | 0 |
Travis Kelce | 192 | 13,002 | 82 | 11 | 4 | 3 |
Rob Gronkowski | 143 | 9,286 | 92 | 5 | 4 | 4 |
If we are looking at the most reasonable GOAT argument, it comes down to this trio of legends, with another former Chief in Tony Gonzalez and Kelce both having by far the most compelling arguments. Gronkowski might have an edge in rings, but this doesn't take into account that one of these was won while the tight end was yet again on injured reserve and unable to contribute.
Gronkowski simply doesn't have the yardage or sustained career, making it a clear two-player race with Gonzalez and Kelce competing for the title. While the current Hall-of-Famer in Gonzalez may have the edge in the statistical department, this doesn't take into account the nearly 80 more games played than Kelce, as well as playoff performance, which is where Kelce's argument becomes undeniable.
The future first ballot Hall-of-Famer blows Gronk out of the water and has just one more former Chief to compete with
Kelce leads tight ends all-time with 2,078 yards of additional production in the playoffs to go along with 20 receiving touchdowns on a ridiculous 81% catch rate. These aren't empty calories, but elite production that fueled Super Bowl runs and gave Patrick Mahomes a reliable target when the franchise needed it most. Gronk is trailing this by nearly 700 yards, while Gonzalez is nowhere to be seen due to the lack of playoff experience.
No question, Kelce has the regular season edge on Gronk and surpasses Gonzalez when it comes to playoff production. What makes the pass catcher's case all the more compelling is the fact that last season, in a struggling offense, the tight end was the team's leading receiver at this late stage of his career.
There is also the fact that Kelce's book is still being written, as more stats and potentially another championship ring to be added. This would make his case undeniable. Whether you judge by postseason greatness, all-time stats, or staying power, there is an argument for Kelce in all three categories.
Add us as a preferred source on Google