Jan 14, 2013; Kansas City, MO, USA; Kansas City Chiefs general manager John Dorsey speaks during the press conference announcing his hiring at the University of Kansas Hospital Training Complex. Mandatory Credit: Denny Medley-USA TODAY Sports

NFL Trade Rumors: Did Chiefs Offer Fifth Round Pick for Tony Gonzalez?

The NFL trade deadline came and went without the Chiefs making a deal. How that will impact the rest of the season will be determined over the next few months, but for now we will try to figure out if the Chiefs were anywhere close to making a deal for any of the players that were reported to be available.

Marty McDonald, famous for his “Save our Chiefs” movement that helped with the ouster of the Scott Pioli era, says he knows something no other journalist knows (so far, anyway).

Later, Carrington Harrison, a radio host for 610 Sports in Kansas City, sent this tweet:

The reply…

A few things to note right off the bat here:

1. No other journalist is running with this story, including Harrison. In fact, Harriston tweeted this later in the day.

2. McDonald does have a history of being right on these things, enough for Harrison to tweet him and ask for his source.

3. Repeat point number one: No one else is running with this story in KC or Atlanta (yet).

The only other mild reference to a potential Gonzalez deal was by Sean Keeler of Fox Sports Kansas City, who wrote this:

Was it a fourth-rounder? A fifth? A third and a conditional? Two sixth-rounders and a $100 gift card at Jack Stack?

The Chiefs-Gonzalez dance picked up serious heat a few weeks ago, got shot down by all the required parties, then picked up heat again Tuesday morning, when Tony G … told ESPN that he ‘would listen’ to offers if Atlanta found a partner that fit.

That’s a lot of dancing on Keeler’s part to say that “he has no idea.”

However, it doesn’t mean there isn’t some smoke to McDonald’s claim, though some of the details may be incorrect by the time we get the full story – and who knows when that will be.

Tony Gonzalez would indeed have been a fit for what the Chiefs offense was lacking. John Dorsey did not shoot down the idea of a trade for Gonzalez, saying: “No, it’s not a no. We have to analyze each situation. That’s kind of what that is.”

We also know the Atlanta Falcons were not sending signals to the public that would suggest they were ready to trade Gonzalez. These signals were very strong as late as yesterday. So it would make sense for the Falcons to ask for something unreasonable, something that would be considered a “win” for the Atlanta organization. A first round pick would be insulting. A third round pick is the highest pick the Chiefs have after that since they traded their second rounder for Alex Smith. A third round pick would not be considered a slap in the face. Make out with a third round pick in this draft, and of course you do that deal if you’re the Falcons.

Otherwise, Atlanta wasn’t having it. Which makes sense because A) they said they didn’t want to trade him and B) Atlanta has not packed it in. A fifth round pick would be tremendous value for a player who intends to walk away in two months, a no-brainer type of trade for a team that’s given up on the season.

So, to some degree, this rumor could be true, but for the moment there is nothing of substance to back it up. File this rumor away for further review.  Eventually there will be a reported story that comes out about how Tuesday went down for Tony Gonzalez, the Atlanta Falcons, and the Kansas City Chiefs.

Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Atlanta Falcons Kansas City Chiefs Tony Gonzalez

11 Comments on NFL Trade Rumors: Did Chiefs Offer Fifth Round Pick for Tony Gonzalez?

  1. Blake Molina says:

    The only way I would’ve considered giving up even a 5th round pick is if we only dealt a 5th round pick and nothing else.

  2. freshmeat62 says:

    By asking for a 3rd, tells me Atl still thinks they have a shot at making the playoffs, which numerically they do. But realistically, they have a pretty rough schedule ahead of them.


    Atlanta SHOULD be packing it in , take a look at their remaining schedule & tell me how they honestly think that they’ll finish the season with anything better than a 5-11 record ….. Thanks for nothing Atlanta , hope the 5th rounder you most likely we’re being offered from us ends up being a diamond in the rough .

  4. Stacy D. Smith says:

    Now that I think about it, Dimitroff is too smart a GM to have publicly waved the white flag on the Falcons’ season. Even if he truly believes it’s over. That could have a lasting effect with the fanbase long after Gonzalez has retired.

    • Ben Nielsen says:

      Have to include ownerships feelings as well. There is a chance Dimitroff wanted to do a deal but was denied by ownership. Lot at play here.

  5. Spellchecker says:

    I would have liked it if the Chief’s were able to get Tony back; but I am glad they didn’t. This sends a message to the players that the management has confidence in their ability and were not willing to mess around with team chemistry unless they were able to make a deal for a reasonable price. Message to Tony Gonzalez–the grass isn’t always greener….

Join The Discussion